Bill McKibben’s a hero, but is he thinking enough about the future when it comes to BAAJA?
I’ll confess that I’ve been torn by the Bipartisan Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA), not least because it is clear that Big Oil is lusting after it and the Republicans—if you still want to call that party by that name—are in favor of it and Trump seems ready to sign it. BAAJA does seem likely to unleash a flood of fossil fuel projects, and especially pipelines in the near term. There are climate heroes of mine arrayed against BAAJA. There are climate heroes of mine supporting BAAJA.
But in the final analysis, I’ve come to believe that BAAJA is about the future of energy and that future is clean energy and clean energy is already well-placed today.
We should be thinking about the next pieces of legislation that celebrate the advantages of clean energy and remove the unfair and unwarranted advantages given to fossil fuels by having the inherent problems with fossil fuels be accounted for: pollution and climate change that kill hundreds of thousands and millions of people each year even while providing conditions that destabilize humans, up to and including resource wars.
This kind of thinking is in line with my view of what should define stories as climate fiction: How do we get from where we are today to a possible better climate future tomorrow. (If you are curious about the definition of climate fiction, check out my post Is It Climate Fiction? Is the genre of climate fiction supposed to mean something?)
Climate is a Long Game
Sure, the worsening climate for humans and the current biosphere is about as serious a condition as any faced by humans over the course of our brief history, and to call this a “game” may seem callous. The fact is that we’ve been playing the game of burning fossil fuels at an ever-increasing rate as our populations have grown exponentially. I’m not interested in debating whether we should have ever started in—after all, humans have been burning things as an essential means toward advancing the scope of our existence, and I’m not one who regrets the 8-billion-plus of human lives existing today. In many ways the success of our species is nothing short of miraculous, even if often at the end of a match, even if we’ve proved to be clumsy and ham-fisted in our relationship to our biosphere. There’s plenty that humans could have and should have done better.
As for today, let’s keep several important realities in mind:
- Trump will continue to fight for fossil fuels until he’s gone;
- Big Oil will continue to fight for itself, and fight dirty, in all the literal and figurative ways it infamously does;
- Big Money (including Big Oil) will always attempt to influence politics;
- The future of fossil fuels must be constrained by orders of magnitude if there is to be a reasonably robust future for humans and a climate that at least somewhat resembles the climate that nurtured the rise of humans as a successful species.
BAAJA is a step forward to build out electrification, but the work of constraining fossil fuels must be a future focus that builds on BAAJA because the building of electricity infrastructure will remove current barriers to clean energy and the clean energy transition is now clearly superior, both in terms of reducing carbon emissions and in straightforward economic competitiveness. However, we can’t expect Big Oil to succumb to the superior energy technologies either graciously or fairly. There’s no historical record to suggest such a possibility. It becomes incumbent on the people and their representatives in government to continue to pass laws that further remove Big Oil’s unfair and dangerous market advantages and mitigate the damage to our ecosphere already done.
I see nothing in BAAJA that prevents future legislation from acknowledging the damage of fossil fuels and defining solutions to that damage up to and including nationalization of the fossil fuel industry, prosecution of fossil fuel corporations for damages, and prosecution of key corporate personnel on the grounds of endangerment. There are plenty of legal precedents: think tobacco (Big Tobacco), Opioids (Big Pharma), and the asbestos trials (Johnson & Johnson and other manufacturers), to name just a few big ones.
I see no reason why the likely new gas pipelines won’t be empty soon enough because they’ll prove uneconomical when fossil fuel corporations and sub-contractors must take measures, for example, to ensure that methane leakage no longer occurs. Do you know that in the United States, estimates put total abandoned and orphaned oil and gas wells at roughly 3.7 million, with about 58% (around 2.1 to 2.2 million) estimated to be unplugged? Globally, a 2025 study mapped over 4.5 million abandoned oil and gas wells across 127 countries, though exact counts of uncapped or actively leaking wells remain incomplete because millions of older wells are undocumented. The astonishing methane plumes from active facilities also are a problem, as are pipeline leaks.
We have every right to require gas companies to stop stinking up our air. Legislation that insists oil companies clean up just this mess alone could create an uneconomical environment for them. There are plenty of other economically adverse challenges for Big Oil in various “Make Polluters Pay” legislation. Let the bastards build and then make them act in accordance with the reality that their polluting and dangerous products don’t get to ignore the costs of their production.
You want lower energy costs? Go green, dude. Don’t want pollution? Pass laws against it. Pollution and permitting reform are not synonymous.
But Big Oil is a Sneaky Bastard
Climate activists and legislatures need to prepare against coming arguments that will be made by Big Oil. The main argument—not yet made because, well, they are still sitting in the catbird seat—will be stranded assets and the implied cost of such stranded assets to the economy.
BAAJA will unleash a boom in pipeline building and natural gas-fired electricity generation plants. It is unclear just how much will get built and there are supply chain and cost constraints to be faced that will delay construction and raise costs, including some of Trump’s own tariffs. The likely even bigger supply chain problems affect clean and dirty energy grid build out alike—transformers and basic building material have extensive and expensive supply chain timelines problems.
Let’s say the worst fears from BAAJA come to pass, and there are slews of new pipelines supplying a whole bunch of gas generation plants even as new transmission grids help connect both these generators and some portion of the 2,600 GW of clean energy projects waiting for connection to the grid. First, the cost of natural gas electricity generation is now more than clean energy generation, so these plants are off to a start that is already economically worse positioned, and the future cost of oil and gas—even absent yet another resource war—will only rise in production costs within the ebb and flow of the supply market, even as clean energy benefitting from economy of scale is still producing lower and lower costs.
Big Oil, in partnership with many Big Utilities, has a simple and logical-sounding argument: we’ve already built these pipelines and generation plants, and we’re still pumping wells like crazy, so let’s keep using them instead of letting them go out of service. Just because clean energy is less expensive over time, that still requires investment in building clean energy projects that replace our gas-fired plants, so why should ratepayers pay for new capital investment? Heck, we have 20, 30, 50 years left of lifetime service on all these gas plants and pipelines! Besides that, placing these existing projects into stranded asset status will hurt our investors, including x-number of pension plans and 401K retirement investments, so let it ride, dude!
Rest assured that Big Oil and some portion of for-profit utility giants will be more than happy to hold the economy hostage so that they can continue burning down the world.
Of course, the right laws can ameliorate and compensate for losses, such as with pension and retirement funds. What must not happen is to protect private equity of major shareholders. The climate writing has been on the wall long enough to get read and understood and those who continue to invest in Big Oil should take the losses that come from bad investments. Who else should be allowed to take it on the chin? The C-suite executives and their stock compensation packages, since they carry a fiduciary responsibility to avoid pouring good money after bad.
And if the United States needs to nationalize the fossil fuel industry to take on that industry’s drawdown of investment and stranded assets, so be it.
Building the Future, One Law at a Time
Bill McKibben recently posted to his Substack, The Crucial Years, from RE+ 2026—the largest clean energy trade show in North America, taking place at the Las Vegas Convention Center. His post, titled If BAAJA passes, then what? The energy future, viewed from the floor of the world’s biggest renewables trade show, starts this way: “Sometime late tonight or tomorrow, it seems highly likely that the Senate will pass the ‘permitting reform’ legislation doing business under the name ‘BAAJA’ for Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act.” He’s been urging the bill’s defeat.

The Crucial Years, as always, is a crucial read, even when I may disagree with a specific point or other on McKibben’s part. Bill McKibben is a hero to me and I’ve had the pleasure of telling him this as he was signing Here Comes the Sun for me. (By the way, another climate hero is Senator Sheldon Whitehouse, in case you’re wondering!)
In the end, despite our differences on BAAJA, McKibben and I hold largely congruent views, including that there’s a lot more work for climate progress still to do. He ends his essay with the following:
The best argument I’ve heard for permitting reform came from Jigar Shah, longtime clean energy advocate, who said at the Vegas convention this afternoon that the permitting reform set up a “fair foot race” between clean energy and dirty, adding, as he pointed to the businesspeople around him, “I believe in you guys.” I fear, of course, that he’s not correct, and that in fact BAJAA ties a heavy rock to the ankle of solar and wind. But if he’s right, or close to it, then victory still depends on the clean energy industry telling its story in ways that connect with people—in building the information apparatus to compete with the absurd but effective myths of the fossil fuel guys.
We’re in a new world, we’ve got to figure out the rules, and we’ve got to fight like hell. As if everything depends on it, because it does.
There are challenging stories to tell for climate progress, including the disappointing truth that there is a whole lot of investment we need to make with both time and money, so affordability of energy is not an immediate universal outcome, but instead will take time for these investments to produce widely shared results. I’ve recently posted Climate Progress is Expensive: Not easing the climate crisis is far more costly, but there’s danger if we’re not upfront about the costs, addressing the work still ahead of us and its potential conflict with the more immediate demands for lower energy prices, yet another story that needs honest communication.

I’m working on the last book in The Steep Climes Quartet, which means I’m trying to prognosticate what the country—and climate—is like in 2047. One part of the story is about the conflict between the so-called “Gradualists” who believe the fossil fuel industry should be allowed to chart its own course “responsibly” and those—mainly the young, and quite vigorously—who think Big Oil should be ended, not coddled. This part of the story is seen mainly in the granddaughter of Davin, the main throughline character, who in 2047 is 82 years of age. The granddaughter, who has been calling herself Hope, is 17 and trying to avoid possible arrest from a San Diego demonstration she’s taken part in, and she’s being helped across the country to Davin’s house in the Berkshires by the Grams, an informal group of climate activists that grew out of McKibben’s The Third Act.
What side of 2.0 Celsius 2047 finds itself on is still being settled, but I’m looking at 2.1 Celsius, I’m sorry to say.
And, of course, as a writer I have my own worry about stranded assets, so please check out the first three books of The Steep Climes Quartet —Kill Well, Dear Josephine, and Over Brooklyn Hills—here and keep an eye open for the last book, Farm to Me, aiming for a Spring 2027 publication date.